014. The famous football match in no man's land in 1914
The German army bypassed the strong French forts by attacking through neutral Belgium, and it was Belgium that shifted the mood of the British public in favor of war. The British press was filled with sensational stories of rape, mutilation, and the ruthless murder of prisoners, allegedly committed by the Germans in Belgium. The German army was portrayed as "a great gang of Jack the Rippers." German propaganda, meanwhile, focused on the British use of dum-dum bullets and Black soldiers.
However, on Christmas Day 1914, the soldiers at the front on both sides easily cast aside this propaganda, celebrating Christmas with the famous unofficial truce and a game of football.
1. The original political catastrophe
The First World War was the original catastrophe for Europe and Western civilization.
Buchanan described it as: "The great civil war of the West, in which the once-Christian nations of Europe turned on one another with such barbaric ferocity that they brought down all their empires, ended centuries of Western dominance, and hastened the death of their civilization."
Eight million soldiers perished in the First World War alone. Twenty million more were wounded, fell ill, were maimed, or coughed up blood as a result of gas attacks.
British soldiers on their way back from the trenches. Photo Flandres Today.
Charles Mee, whose grandfather lost all ten of his brothers in the war, wrote: "A generation had been decimated. No one had ever seen such slaughter before."
It was especially after the First World War that Europeans lost faith in their own civilization. Many became convinced that something entirely different was needed. Marxism, anarchism, and syndicalism flourished, sparking unrest and revolutions everywhere.
2. The Football Match in No Man's Land
But for a brief moment during the great slaughter, there was a light in the darkness - a glimmer of hope.
Late on Christmas Eve 1914, British soldiers heard the Germans in the trenches opposite them singing Christmas hymns and patriotic songs, and saw lights and small fir trees along their trenches. They began calling messages to one another across No Man's Land.
German and British soldiers meet in no man's land during the unofficial truce on the Western Front on Christmas Day, 1914. Photo: Imperial War Museum.
The following day, British and German soldiers met in No Man's Land, exchanging cigarettes and small gifts. Photographs were taken, and some played an improvised game of football. They also buried the dead and repaired the trenches. After Boxing Day, these encounters in No Man's Land gradually ceased.
This unofficial truce is documented by old photographs and numerous letters that the soldiers sent home. It did not occur along the entire front line, but evidently took place in many locations. There are several accounts of football being played on the frozen ground of No Man's Land.
Some say they merely kicked around an empty tin can, while others claim they played with a bundle of rags tied together. There are also accounts suggesting that a real football was used, provided by either the Germans or the British. Some report that the soldiers marked out two goals using stones or similar objects and played an organized game, while others describe hundreds of young men simply running around happily, chasing the ball.
Reconstruction of the famous football match. Photo 1914-Sainsbury's Ad - Christmas 2014. Youtube.
On January 1, 1915, The Times published a letter from a major in the Medical Corps, who reported that in his sector, after the Saxons had sung "God Save the King" to "our men," one of his men received "a bottle of wine to drink the King's health," whereupon his regiment "actually had a football match against the Saxons, who beat them 3 2!!!"
"Wherever you looked, the occupants of the trenches were standing around talking to one another, and even playing football."
An account from Kurt Zehmisch, of the 134th Saxon Regiment, states: "Eventually, the English brought a football from their trenches, and quite quickly a lively match ensued."
And Sergeant Major Frank Nadin of the 6th Cheshire Regiment described a fight as "a rare old jollification.".
Sculpture in Stoke-on-Trent, England, commemorating the Christmas Truce on the Western Front in 1914. An English soldier and a German soldier greet each other over a football. Photo latimer.com
There are credible accounts of at least one match involving a real football. Ernie Williams, of the 6th Cheshire Regiment, recounted in a 1983 television interview: "The ball appeared from somewhere - I don t know where - but it came from their side; it didn t come from ours. They set up some goals, and - well, there was just a general kickabout. I d say a couple of hundred men took part - Everyone seemed to be enjoying themselves. There was no ill will between us. There was no referee, no scorekeeping - no record of goals at all. It was simply a free-for-all."
The existence of so many different accounts of football matches suggests, that they took place in several locations along the front line. This is quite plausible; after all, the British spoke English and the Germans spoke German, and once they had exchanged cigarettes, shared a toast, and shaken hands, they must have been looking for other ways to demonstrate their good will. They were all young men longing to have a normal life - so what could be more natural than playing football?
3. International sporting events are peace-promoting
It would have been a blessing for Europe if the events on the Western Front on Christmas Eve 1914 had developed into widespread fraternization and the disintegration of the armies. They did not. The war continued, and as the soldiers watched their comrades fall, mutual hatred grew, as it did among the families behind the front lines.
Demonstration for Tibetan independence and a boycott of the Beijing Olympics in February 2022, in Lausanne at the IOC headquarters. Photo Rizhwickh Wikipedia.
However, if we consider the football matches on Christmas Eve in 1914 to have been a positive event, one that moved things in the right direction, then we cannot simultaneously support the practice of boycotts and exclusions in international sport. Logically, if serious tensions arise between two nations, it should be even more urgent to organize sporting events between them, to prevent the situation from escalating into a political catastrophe akin to the First World War.
Today, it has become common practice to exclude athletes from nations we dislike, through boycotts or outright bans, from international sporting events. This is likely driven by subtle geopolitical agendas, or simply by a desire on the part of politicians to demonstrate to their voters that they are taking action.
In 1976, African nations boycotted the Montreal Olympics, expressing their dissatisfaction with New Zealand s sporting ties to South Africa in cricket and rugby. In 1980, the United States boycotted the Moscow Olympics in response to the Soviet Union s invasion of Afghanistan. In retaliation, the entire Eastern Bloc boycotted the 1984 Los Angeles Olympics. When Russia invaded Ukraine in 2022, both Russia and Belarus were immediately excluded from all international sporting events, including the FIFA World Cup.
Gay people demonstrate in favor of a boycott of the Winter Olympic Games in Sochi, because the Russian Duma had passed laws prohibiting the "promotion of homosexuality among minors". Photo golosameriki.com
In fact, at almost every international sporting event, politicians appear who promote themselves by calling for boycotts or exclusions.
The exclusion of Russia and Ukraine from all international sporting events following the 2022 invasion of Ukraine required no demonstrations; it happened almost instantly and must have been carefully prepared. This is likely because the United States fears losing the global hegemony it gained in 1945, should Russia s resources and Western Europe s industrial and commercial talents ever join forces.
If we truly believe that boycotts and exclusions from international sporting events are appropriate tools in the arena of international politics, then, logically, we must also consider the football matches played in no-man s-land on Christmas Eve 1914 to have been an act of pure treason. All the teams should have been excluded, and the players boycotted and brought before a military court-martial. After all, there were extreme political tensions between their two nations - a state of war, in fact - and such fraternization is simply unacceptable.