DH Debate Club Logo

Dalum Hjallese Debate Club

010. Expansive fiscal policy involving arms production

It was John Maynard Keynes's ideas about expansionary fiscal policy that helped the world getting out from the mass unemployment of the 1930s. However, for his theory to have a beneficial impact on national economies, certain conditions must be met: there must actually be a domestic pool of unemployed labor ready to go to work, earn an income, and spend it. Furthermore, the economy must be sufficiently national in scope, so that these newly employed workers purchase goods and services produced within the country's own borders. Clearly, an expansionary fiscal policy would also fail if import of foreign labor is needed to carry out the projects.
For example Denmark is a small, globalized economy. In such a context, an expansionary fiscal policy would be a complete non-starter-fizzling out like a damp firecracker because the money would be used for import of all kinds and no create employment. Yet, for very large economies, such as the United States, China, or Russia, an expansionary fiscal policy could still serve to "get the wheels turning."
Moreover, Russia possesses the advantage of having a largely national economy, a situation driven by political conditions. Consequently, it is easy to see how a substantial increase in arms production must have had a highly favorable effect on the employment and then nation's economy.

You'll have to explain to me how producing weapons creates jobs and growth. Besides, we aren't really allowed to produce much more in Europe. Nor are we even capable of it. You might as well just pay people to be on welfare as have them produce weapons, that you end up using yourself. Just think about how the flow of money works. Then try again to claim that it actually generates profit. Sure, if you can sell them to vassal states, it might bring in a little bit, but the US arms industry is a massive net loss, no matter how you look at it.

An expansionary fiscal policy driven by the production of weapons will not work in Denmark and Western Europe today.

John Maynard Keynes wrote in his famous open letter to President Roosevelt in 1933:

"Thus, as the primary factor in the initial phase of the recovery strategy, I place overwhelming emphasis on the increase in national purchasing power resulting from government spending financed through borrowing rather than through the taxation of current incomes." - "Consequently, war has always triggered intense industrial activity. In the past, orthodox economics viewed war as the only legitimate justification for generating employment through public expenditure. You, Mr. President, having cast off such shackles, are free to employ this technique, which has hitherto been permitted only for the purposes of war and destruction, in the service of peace and prosperity."

And that was precisely what we did in Denmark in the thirties. We built the Little Belt Bridge and the Storstrøm Bridge, carried out excavations of Aggersborg, and undertook other projects, all of which reduced unemployment and stimulated the demand and thus national economy. They did the same in Germany, where they built the Autobahn.

Producing weapons is presumably just as good as building Little Belt Bridges. Keynes believed that the multiplier effect could operate with a factor of 10.

However, for an expansionary fiscal policy to have a beneficial effect on the national economy, there must actually be a pool of available labor, ready to go to work, earn money, and spend them, and that is not the case in Denmark today.

Denmark's economy today is completely different from, what it was in the 1930s. In a small, globalized economy like Denmark's, the vast majority of goods found in stores are manufactured in countries very far from the point of sale. Most consumer goods are produced in China or Vietnam, vegetables come from Southern Europe, software from the United States, cars from Germany, and so on. An expansionary fiscal policy in an economy such as this would have very little effect, it would be a complete failure, since the multiplier effect for the national economy would likely be negligible. It would indeed stimulate economic activity, but it would do so in China, Southern Europe, Silicon Valley, and many other far-flung places.

Therefore, Keynes was right for his time, but the premises have changed.

But Russia, for example, finds itself in a completely different situation. It had a rather sluggish economy, with some level of unemployment, that has received a major boost from a sharp increase in arms production. Russia's economy is far more nationally oriented than Denmark's. Workers in the arms industry will spend their rubles on Russian-made products, thereby stimulating activity across many other sectors within Russia.

But of course, we in Denmark should produce weapons, because we need them. However, we shouldn't imagine that this does much to "get the wheels turning."

Titorelli 20240312