DH Debate Club Logo

Dalum Hjallese Debate Club Logo

004. Welfare benefits are irreversible within the framework of a democracy

In a modern democracy, an ever-increasing number of welfare benefits arrive in a steady stream. There are always people, who are seen as deserving of sympathy, and political parties use them to maximize their vote share in competition with other parties. One should not imagine that an alternative political majority could simply abolish these benefits. In time, any given welfare benefit will sink deep into the public consciousness and come to be perceived as a fair, well-earned entitlement.

Welfare benefits are, in principle, irreversible within the framework of a modern democratic system.

The unrest in France in connection with Macron's efforts to raise the retirement age demonstrates that an alternative parliamentary majority cannot simply abolish the benefits.

Democracy has always been associated with the idea that everyone owns one another's property and can tax or confiscate it based on the decisions of the majority.

Aeschines was a politician from Athens, a contemporary of Plato and Socrates. In the context of a discussion regarding such forms of taxation and confiscation, he offers the following comment: "The Athenians emerge from the Ecclesia (Athens' popular assembly) not as if they are coming from a political gathering, but as if they are leaving a business meeting where the profits have been distributed."

There is always someone who is to be pitied. Benefits arrive in a steady, continuous stream, hich is impossible to resist within a democratic system, because voters can vote themselves access to other people's money.

The modern democratic system - with the right to vote extended to women, teenagers, and Muslim immigrants - enables Social Democratic parties to corrupt the voters with welfare benefits, funded by taxes squeezed out of "the rich."

Several French governments - most recently Macron's - have attempted to make the French labor market more flexible and to raise the retirement age. However, about two-thirds of the French people remain adamant that early retirement is their historical right. Ignoring increased life expectancy and the fact that their country is being taken over by Muslims, they insist on this "right", even though the retirement age in France is already one of the lowest in Europe.

Some early retirement scheme is a good example of an arrangement that was intended to be temporary, due to unemployment, but which quickly became an established right that cannot be revoked. Originally, the scheme was meant to allow older employees to retire, thereby making room for unemployed young people.

Danish welfare benefits - also for EU citizens - which are truly irreversible within the framework of a modern democratic system, already comprise hundreds of different benefits:

Her are some of the benefits

General services

Maternity/paternity benefits
Unemployment benefits
Cash benefits (social help)
Unemployment benefit for persons in subsidized employment (ledighedsydelse)
Vocational rehabilitation benefits
Starting allowance (starthjælp)
Sickness benefits
Introduction allowance
Cash benefits within the asylum system: basic allowance, supplement for those with dependents, additional allowance
State Educational Grant and Loan Scheme (SU) in Denmark and abroad (including transport discounts, scholarships for study abroad to cover tuition fees, etc.)
Adult Vocational Training (VEU) allowance (including transport discounts)
Early retirement pay (efterløn)
Flexible job (subsidized employment)
Flexible job allowance (fleksydelse)
State old-age pension (folkepension)
Early retirement pension (disability pension)
Reintegration assistance

Sevices - children and young people

Daycare services (nursery, kindergarten, daycare, etc.), including: subsidies and placement in the municipality of residence, sibling discounts, fee waivers (subsidies for free or reduced-cost places), subsidies and placement in another municipality, meals in daycare institutions, and subsidies for private institutions
Subsidies for the care of one's own children
Subsidies for private childcare
After-school care (leisure centers), including: subsidies and placement in the municipality of residence, subsidies and placement in another municipality, sibling discounts, fee waivers, meals, subsidies for municipal and self-governing after-school centers within the municipality, and subsidies for private after-school centers
Club activities and other socio-pedagogical leisure offerings for older children and young people, including: subsidies and placement in the municipality of residence, subsidies and placement in another municipality, fee waivers, and sibling discounts

Services - disability assistance

Activity and social engagement services
Protected employment
Home adaptations
Citizen-controlled personal assistance
Consumer goods
Assistive devices
Individual transport
Contact person scheme for the deafblind
Companion scheme, including: for young people aged 16–18, and for adults aged 18 and over
Compensation for additional expenses: coverage of necessary extra costs resulting from a child's disability or an individual's functional impairment
Temporary stay in a residential facility
Care for a close relative with a disability or serious illness
Care allowance
Social-pedagogical support
Support for the purchase of a car
Specialized day-care services for children with disabilities
Specialized club activities for children with disabilities
Compensation for loss of earnings for parents caring for a child at home
Treatment-oriented services
Free counseling services for individuals with physical or mental impairments or specific social challenges
Interpretation services for individuals with hearing impairments
Permanent residence, housing options

Services - vulnerable individuals

Placement outside the home
Consultancy services
Pedagogical support in the home
Family therapy
Respite care
Contact person
Facilitation of work placements
Treatment for substance abusers
Aftercare
Free family-oriented counseling
Shelters and care homes
Women's crisis centers

SERVICEYDELSER - ÆLDRE

Independent nursing homes
General services aimed at promoting activity and prevention
Rehabilitation
Home care services, including: assistance or support with necessary practical tasks in the home, personal care and assistance, cash grants for hiring a caregiver, and meal services
Nursing homes and sheltered housing
Respite care or relief services for relatives caring for a person with a disability or reduced functional capacity
Preventive home visits for all citizens aged 75 and older
Temporary residential stays for individuals who, for a period, have a specific need for care and support
Maintenance training

SERVICES – HEALTHCARE SECTOR
Services - heakthcare sector Alcohol and drug abuse treatment
Treatment by general practitioners and medical specialists
Public travel health insurance
Preventive health services, including public health nursing
Rehabilitation
Home nursing
Municipal dental care
Regional dental care
Hospital treatment
Subsidies for treatment by dentists, chiropractors, physiotherapists, podiatrists, and psychologists
Subsidies for medicines
Vaccinations
Free-of-charge physiotherapy

Services - Teaching

Vocational/Profession education and training: EUD, AER
Primary and lower secondary education: Folkeskolen (public schools), independent primary and lower secondary schools, efterskoler (residential schools), mother-tongue instruction
Upper secondary education: stx, hhx, htx, hf, IB (including grants for IB education abroad)
SPS (special educational support)
Student travel cards (transport discounts for students in upper secondary education)
Higher education: Academy profession and professional bachelor's degree programmes, bachelor's and master's degree programmes, tuition waivers and scholarships, programmes offered abroad
Adult and continuing education: AVU, FVU, AMU, academy and diploma programmes, folkehøjskoler (folk high schools)

SUPPLEMENTARY SERVICES – SOCIAL
Supplementary services - social
Housing subsidy (Boligsikring)
Housing benefit (Boligydelse)
Child supplement
Bereavement assistance
One-off benefits under the Active Social Policy Act
Health supplement
Personal supplement
Special rules regarding assistance for certain groups of people
Heating supplement
Child and youth benefit ("child check")
Relocation and establishment grant under the Public Housing Act
Repatriation support
Disability supplement for students

Supplementary services - health

Transportation and transportation allowance
Funeral assistance
Subsidies for nutritional supplements
Interpretation services
Source: Rapport om optjeningsprincipper i forhold til danske velfærdsydelser, marts 2011.

Furthermore, for state pensioners: inflation relief, media allowance, pensioner's supplement, reduced property value tax, and additional financial support for recipients of the pensioner's supplement.

Ældresagen Supplements and subsidies.

Titorelli 20230317